Wednesday – ‘Bleeds’ album review: A patchwork of chaotic elegance
There’s something inherently messy about trying to put life into words, especially in this moment, when everything external also makes little sense. In Bleeds, Wednesday takes the violent scratchings of diary-like confessions and makes them into a kaleidoscope of raw reflections.
There’s an abrasive, dramatic flair that comes with this record before you’re even halfway through the opening track. The album artwork, the title, and the overarching malaise attached to the concepts of Wednesdays immediately feel engraved with something darker, more sinister. But while this exists on the surface, beginning with ‘Reality TV Argument Bleeds’, these recollections are anything but hostile.
As Karly Hartzman views it, it’s not a dark record but one with “southern gothic attitude”, sounding “a little bit scary, but with a heart of gold underneath”. As such, the record has many of Wednesday’s familiar traits: pulling from the threads of their shoegaze, country infusion, with a headiness around a softer, gooey centre. Mainly, it feels like it reaches the point Wednesday were always heading for, all parts coming together with a sudden ease as they’ve finally cracked their own formula.
Much of the guitar distortion, like in ‘Townies’ and ‘Wound Up Here’, feels especially pronounced and like some kind of punctuating factor interrupting Hartzman’s train of thought. In ‘Candy Breath’, this goes hand-in-hand with the feeling of a strained relationship paired with an almost comedic resignation. All the while, the band pinballs between different sounds and styles in a way that makes simple shoegaze and country labels feel entirely reductive.
Mostly, where they shine the most is during the more tender moments. ‘Elderberry Wine’, ‘The Way Love Goes’ and ‘Carolina Murder Suicide’ ground the emotional core of the record, feeling especially hefty amid the chaos of the surrounding tracks in all their raw, gritty glory. ‘The Way Love Goes’ is more heartfelt in its simplicity as Hartzman ruminates on not giving enough in a relationship, and knowing there are other women “much more patient with much more than I can give”.
It all comes together in a mismatched patchwork, sometimes with clashing moments of both tragedy and humour. But that’s what makes it feel real, and like Wednesday’s most accomplished work yet. In songs like ‘Townies’ and ‘Phish Pepsi’, we’re invited to have fun in the misty haze of it all, because, sometimes life is as ridiculous as: “We watched a Phish concert and Human Centipede /Two things I now wish I’d never seen”.
It says a lot about a record when there’s almost too much to say about it. And what’s often the case with these self-referential, confessional-style pieces is that they can venture off into vague territory, saying things that sound important but which mean nothing at all. With Bleeds, however, everything feels grounded in something real. Everything has roots somewhere deep, even as we smile and laugh along with the absurdity of it all.
Defining track: ‘The Way Love Goes’ – a simpler loverlorn track that somehow anchors the artistic vision of the entire record.
For fans of: Facing up to your demons, but looking damn good while doing it.
A concluding comment from a Phish fan: “Real”.
Release date: September 19th, 2025 | Producer: Alex Farrar | Label: Dead Oceans
Never Miss A Beat
The Far Out New Music Newsletter
All the latest New Music from the independent voice of culture.
Straight to your inbox.