In 1973, one in every 350 Americans went to a single Grateful Dead show: “We’re one of the last adventures”
When reflecting on the 1960s, Hunter S Thompson would write, “Maybe it meant something. Maybe not, in the long run, but no explanation, no mix of words or music or memories can touch that sense of knowing that you were there and alive in that corner of time and the world. Whatever it meant.”
By and large, whatever it meant seems to have become vastly intangible.
Now, endless polemics still battle to bottle a fleeting wisp of its bygone meaning. But while many argue that its vague spirit died with the literal close of the ‘60s – at Woodstock perhaps – in actual fact, it may well have culminated a few years later.
Only four years after the iconic Woodstock in ‘69, on hot and dry July 28th in ‘73, at the same upstate New York venue, The Grateful Dead joined the Allman Brothers and The Band on a line-up which would bring in well over half a million people. It would be one of the most impressive performances of all time.
While, as many men have continually insisted, size isn’t everything, you can’t deny the profound impact of one in every 350 Americans gathering in the same field. The numbers speak for themselves.
The seismic Summer Jam, as the Grateful Dead’s headline show was dubbed, saw 600,000 very friendly people experience the freedom that the ‘60s fought for in a last hurrah of unified camaraderie. Yet, strangely, this event seems to have been overshadowed in the aftermath.
Were you there?
It was only $10 a ticket, and that included parking and camping ($75 in 2026). It was a positive free-for-all and one that attracted a swathe of the rock and roll generation. It was, for a time, the entry in the Guinness Book of World Records as the “largest audience at a pop festival”. And that was in ‘73, at a time when the population of the US was only 62% of what it is today.
But its size was purely indicative of its significance rather than the source of it. More so than a ‘pop festival’, the Summer Jam almost functioned like a pop-up civilisation.
On the afternoon of the day before the event, the organisers had achieved their goal and sold 125,000 tickets, confirming it as a sell-out. It meant that the financers were happy to leave the gates open and allow the extra half a million people to amble in unimpeded. That alone is vaguely revolutionary. When was the last time capitalism declared it had had its fill?
Often described as the biggest youth movement of the time, in Robert Santinelli’s book Aquarius Rising he more accurately portrays the festival’s vastness: “Many historians claimed that the Watkins Glen event was the largest gathering of people in the history of the United States.” And they were all listening to liberated rock ‘n’ roll in harmony, mostly for free. That’s not nothing. It must have been quite the sight for the small town of 2,700 people playing host.
Santinelli startlingly continues, “Considering that most of those who attended the event hailed from the Northeast and that the average age of those present was approximately seventeen to twenty-four, close to one out of every three young people from Boston to New York was at the festival.” Again, that’s not nothing.
The legacy of the Watkins Glen gathering
So, why has it been overshadowed? Well, somehow, despite the huge numbers of people, crime remained minimal. Although there was an abundance of nudity, drugs, and claims of a stolen pig from a nearby farm, the festival went by relatively unscathed. All in all, the event saw four road deaths, 50 arrests and one birth. (Though, rather mysteriously, two teenagers also disappeared on their way to the site).
In short, that’s where the crux of the story lies. This historic gathering was, in effect, a gargantuan socialist free-for-all that didn’t succumb to chaos, bankruptcy, or the fall of civilisation, as many conservative commentators might have otherwise predicted. On the contrary, it offered 600,000 Americans a glimpse at a near-utopian alternative.
When reflecting on the decade that the Grateful Dead had just overseen in 1969, frontman Jerry Garcia commented, “It wasn’t a gig, it was the Acid Tests, where anything was ok.”
He continued, “Thousands of people, man, all helplessly stoned, all finding themselves in a roomful of other thousands of people, none of whom any of them were afraid of. It was magic, far-out, beautiful magic.” Stoned or otherwise, that’s the general consensus on Summer Jam too, reflected by the 0.29% of America peacefully present at the sun-baked occasion.
As the openers and headliners for the event, The Grateful Dead performed two sets. As well as bringing out some classics like opening with ‘Bertha’ and giving run-outs to ‘Jack Straw’, ‘Box of Rain’ and ‘Wharf Rat’, they also covered the likes of Johnny Cash’s ‘Big River’ and ‘Promised Land’ by Chuck Berry. The mammoth double set also provided covers of Merle Haggard and Marty Robbins. It’s vintage Dead and saw the band nearing the peak of their powers.
But above all, it saw them defining their timeless appeal. While the ‘60s might have died, the Dead were destined to live on and offer a weird window to a world away from the humdrum, mechanical grind of the norm. As we found out when we spoke to Robert Mooney, a New York homicide detective who worked on over 1,500 murder cases, but also attended around “250 or 300” shows by the Dead along the way.
In stark contrast to his day job, he argued, “The community that exists at the shows, and even when you’re not there, is everybody’s just nice to everybody else. There’s a lot of kindness. There’s a lot of concern for other people.” It impacted the detective profoundly.
“That sort of socialisation allowed me to have a much more open mind about the kind of stuff I would deal with in the police,” Mooney would explain. “You’re much more accepting of people that are a little bit different, their culture is a little bit different, or they’re from different ethnic or racial backgrounds. There’s nothing in the Grateful Dead experience that people ever do to exacerbate problems in those worlds. Everybody wants everybody else to be happy and have fun.”
That spirit brought order to the Summer Jam, and ironically, despite the mammoth implication regarding the importance of peaceful community and togetherness – more vital now than ever – largely kept it out of the headlines. ‘This big thing happened and it was nice and everybody had a good time’ doesn’t sell papers – especially when the papers are owned by oligarchs with a vested interest to keep that sort of communal harmony quiet. It was a spirit that also kept many of the 600,000 in attendance coming back to the Grateful Dead’s gigs.
Their shows represent friendly freedom, and in the wake of Summer Jam, that has sadly been increasingly amiss in society to the extent that the band even grew puzzled about their continued appeal, with Garcia commenting in an apt conclusion in 1991, “Here we are getting into our 50s, and where are these people who keep coming to our shows coming from?”
He added, “What do they find so fascinating about these middle-aged bastards playing basically the same thing we’ve always played? There must be a dearth of fun out there in America. Or adventure. Maybe we’re one of the last adventures in America. I don’t know.”
Perhaps, they were the last cooperative community, too. As Bob Dylan said in praise of the band, “With most bands the audience participates like in a spectator sport. They just stand there and watch. They keep a distance. With the Dead, the audience is part of the band-they might as well be on the stage.”
Pete Townshend also weighed on the matter, explaining, “The big thing about the Dead I remember, was that they gave their road crew the same share that they got themselves, did you know that?” said Townshend, “Yeah, it was a true cooperative, so nobody got rich, nobody. They made a living but they didn’t get rich.”
Those facets combined make Watkins Glen gathering monumental. But they’re also one of the main reasons you might never have heard about it until now.
Never Miss A Tale
The Far Out Classic Rock Newsletter
All the latest Classic Rock content from the independent voice of culture.
Straight to your inbox.