Lime Garden – ‘Maybe Not Tonight’ album review: The best of modern British music
There is a solid case to be made for Lime Garden being the best band in the UK right now, or at least being the band that represents what has always been best about the music of the UK. Their new album, Maybe Not Tonight, isn’t Exhibit A, though. It’s the jury-winning Exhibit B as a follow-up to their 2024 debut.
The Skinny: What’s so great about Great Britain? It seems like all we have right now is economic decline, political unrest, the loss of community, and the rise of the manosphere. Need proof of that last one? Head to YouTube and watch Lime Garden do an incredible cover of New Order’s ‘Age Of Consent’ in the hallowed halls of Abbey Road, and take a peek in the comments to see them being called “a foid band” – the new buzzword way of belittling women in music.
But if there’s the slightest glimmer of hope on this grey and wretched island, it’s the music. Specifically, if the UK has ever had a shining light, it’s the music coming out of garages and cheap rehearsal rooms where groups of friends have morphed into something magic.
In the modern scene, Lime Garden are the ultimate example of that. Forming way back in 2017 at college, the four members grew up together, and across their discography so far, you can hear it. By the time they came to release One More Thing in 2024, their evolution saw them unleash one of the year’s best indie offerings that was packed with bangers like ‘Love Song’ and ‘I Want To Be You’, but also showed their breadth as songs like ‘Floors’ or ‘Pine’ felt like creations that could only come out of a rehearsal room of love and openness.
On that debut, Lime Garden emerged with a singular voice. Informed by a whole variety of references, they quickly felt unmistakable. On this follow-up, that rings true but is endlessly more golden and polished. ‘Always Talking About You’ stands as a high point of that as singer Chloe Howard muses on modern dating like a jester at first, before slamming you with the core gut-punch, succinctly summing up the suggestion that maybe none of us ever get over anything. It’s a song that dances between timeless universality and modern existentialism; a balance Lime Garden have mastered.
Around her, the band weaves a dynamic sonic. That’s another thing that defines all the heroes of British music. All the leading acts in our history seem to operate under the belief that if it works and if it’s exciting, it can stay even if it’s not strictly ‘rock’. Maybe Not Tonight embodies that as while all ten songs are the making of a tight band of rock musicians, each is a world in itself. From the night-out-in-a-bottle, electro-tinged ‘Maybe Not Tonight’, the outright high-octane ‘Body’, the math-rock meets sleaze sound of ‘All Bad Parts’, all these references work seamlessly but only have to make sense to Lime Garden’s own brains.
Maybe that’s the kicker – Lime Garden are a band who know themselves, because they know each other. Best friends don’t need to explain their choices and references, leading to the creation of an album that dynamically embodies how dynamic friendships and the people in them are. It’s the same sauce that led all of the country’s best, allowing for each member’s evolution. As they launch their second incredible offering and a clear step up from their debut, Lime Garden position themselves to keep climbing up in their ranks.
Standout Track: ‘Always Talking About You’
The Verdict: Watching four kids meet, make music of their own accord, practice, play gigs around the nation’s best local venues and shape up into something this great? That’s enough to make you almost patriotic.
Release Date: April 10th, 2026 | Producer: Charlie Andrew and Annabel Whittle | Label: So Young
Never Miss A Beat
The Far Out New Music Newsletter
All the latest New Music from the independent voice of culture.
Straight to your inbox.