Minute by name, minute by nature: Five masterpieces that are under 60 seconds long
People will regularly tell you that the ideal length for a pop song is somewhere between three and four minutes, not simply because this is the length of the average person’s attention span, but that it feels like the perfect duration to be able to squeeze enough good ideas in.
Not all music is created with mass appeal in mind, though, and sometimes this trend of writing perfectly crafted pop music that lasts the optimal length of time can divert from the norm. With this, you end up getting songs that outstay the welcome of most people’s interest, or deliver far less than the typical chart-topping song might.
As someone who has always been a fan of progressive rock and jazz, this means I’m not afraid of a song lasting a little longer than normal or dragging on, but as soon as you start telling the regular folks you share an office job with that your favourite songs are a quarter of an hour long, they’ll begin to stare you down like some sort of freak.
Given social media’s propensity for only allowing us to share snippets of songs, those ogling colleagues of yours are probably right, and you’re in the minority for liking songs with a little bit of meat on them. However, despite this gravitation towards shorter tracks seeming like a way to avoid putting effort in, there are plenty of songs below the three-minute threshold that do more than enough to sate the listener.
While it’s not uncommon for songs to be under three minutes, or even two in some cases, it’s rare to get a full masterpiece that’s under a minute long. Below, we’ve picked out five songs that were evidently ahead of this curve, which are all over before the second hand passes 12 for a second time.
Five masterpiece songs under a minute long:
Wand – ‘Little Dream’
As prolific as they’ve been since the mid-2010s, Cory Hanson and Wand are arguably at their best when their songs are allowed to sprawl, and despite the fact that they’re also evidently good at switching up styles, this lengthy approach to structure tends to favour them on songs where they flit from psychedelic rock to noise to shoegaze.
However, on their third album, 1000 Days, the penultimate song is done and dusted in just over half a minute. ‘Little Dream’ is exactly as the title suggests: a furious garage punk face-melter, and one they ought to be proud of despite it only being a fraction of the length of most of their acclaimed material. Some folks really can just do it all, can’t they?
Jeff Rosenstock – ‘No Time’
If you’ve only got a minute with which to deliver a song, how much do you reasonably think you’d be able to squeeze in? Maybe a single verse and chorus would feel reasonable, but a lot of songs can’t usually fit that much into such a short window. Jeff Rosenstock’s ‘No Time’ manages to have an intro, a verse, a brief chorus, another verse and chorus, a bridge, a final verse and chorus, and an outro, all in a swift 54 seconds.
OK, they skip from one to the other in rapid succession, but there’s a real industriousness to the pop punk master felt on this opening track to his 2020 album, No Dream. If you ever think that you’re writing a song and it needs to be bulked up significantly, think about this song and how everything that’s necessary can be found in miniature form within it. You don’t need more, you need less – this is proof.
Minutemen – ‘Please Don’t Be Gentle With Me’
There aren’t any acts that have officially been anointed as the kings of brevity, but the San Pedro trio Minutemen certainly did their best to live up to their name. While none of their tracks sound like they’re meant to be vignettes, the whole of their 43-track Double Nickels on the Dime miraculously passes by in a whirlwind, and the first song that manages to pass by in less than a minute is perhaps the best.
‘Please Don’t Be Gentle With Me’ is a stumbling art punk masterpiece in its own right, but when heard in the context of their 1984 opus, you realise just how adept the band were at making miniatures feel like epics. It’s a shame that the band came to a tragic and abrupt end in the way that they did, because there was seemingly an endless fountain of inspiration that they were able to tap into 60 seconds at a time, and their philosophy of ‘jamming econo’ brought some of punk’s most creative gems.
Sparks – ‘Propaganda’
Functioning as a tremendous overture for the record, the 23-second ‘Propaganda’ is Sparks at their oddball and glam rock best, but while it might seem like a daft throwaway to kick things off, it actually sets the tone for just how serious Sparks were about following up their first classic album of 1974, Kimono My House, with another of equal magnitude in the record from which the song takes its name.
Yes, it’s incredibly brief, but you can’t help but be completely charmed by its whimsy, and it feels like a complete song rather than something to fill a sub-30-second gap at the start of a record. When it climaxes with Russell Mael’s escalating high notes and runs into the grandiose opening chords of ‘At Home, At Work, At Play’, you know that this isn’t just them messing about; it’s them flexing their compositional muscles to the best of their ability.
The Beatles – ‘Her Majesty’
It may seem unfinished, and given how it was tacked onto the end of Abbey Road as a hidden track, you get the impression that Paul McCartney wanted ‘Her Majesty’ to be shielded from because he hadn’t had the opportunity to ever develop the song beyond one brief verse. However, this only tells half the story of what is arguably the most peculiar McCartney-penned song in The Beatles’ catalogue.
In actuality, ‘Her Majesty’ was conceived as being the track to bridge the gap between ‘Mean Mr Mustard’ and ‘Polythene Pam’ as part of the medley on side two, but because the band weren’t ever able to figure out how to get the three songs to segue into each other smoothly, you realise that its intention of being a genius interlude, and eventual placement as a secret track just feels like a charming coda for those who chose not to lift the needle after ‘The End’.
Never Miss A Beat
The Far Out Beatles Newsletter
All the latest stories about The Beatles from the independent voice of culture.
Straight to your inbox.