Joni Mitchell, Johnny Cash and Bob Dylan at the greatest songwriting party ever
It’s not always the case that the greatest songwriters are immediately going to be able to work well in each other’s company, and that’s why some of them tend not to collaborate.
However, it’s undeniable that being surrounded by creativity can lead to waves of inspiration, and witnessing the creative process of someone like Johnny Cash can be a great source to drink from.
So, when ‘The Man in Black’ throws a big party for all of the most illustrious songwriters in the land to attend, and you’re invited, you’re hardly going to pass up on the opportunity to go along and see what sort of magic can be conjured up. In early 1969, Cash decided to do exactly this, corralling a group of esteemed friends and contemporaries together to showcase some of their works in progress at his home in Hendersonville, Tennessee.
There was no pressure for any of the attendees to work together in this scenario, but it presented more of a relaxed opportunity to receive feedback on songs that were not yet ready to be heard publicly. With the likes of Bob Dylan, Joni Mitchell, Graham Nash, Shel Silverstein and Kris Kristofferson in attendance, it was clear that between the host and his five guests, there was bound to be plenty of brilliance on display, even if the songs they were playing didn’t quite have all of their finishing touches applied.
The reason behind inviting this selection of artists was that Cash knew they were all going to be present in Nashville that evening anyway. Dylan was in the process of recording Nashville Skyline and had been a houseguest at Cash’s place between sessions, while Mitchell and Nash, who were in a relationship at the time, were both guests scheduled to appear on The Johnny Cash Show the same evening, so he extended the invitation to them.
With Kristofferson and Silverstein both happening to be passing through Nashville at an opportune moment, they rounded up the list, making for a remarkable selection of songwriters gathered in one place. While Cash didn’t perform any of his own future hits that night, the others all debuted rough drafts of tracks that would go on to be some of the best-known of their careers.
Dylan was working on ‘Lay Lady Lay’ at the time, which is a well-regarded hit from this era of his career, while Mitchell had ‘Both Sides Now’ to offer up, which despite being a track that many love her for, was only ever a hit for Judy Collins, reaching the Top 10 in the US.
Nash gave a performance of ‘Marrakesh Express’, which ended up being used on Crosby, Still & Nash, while Kristofferson and Silverstein both played songs that were offered up to other performers, with Cash taking ‘A Boy Named Sue’ from Silverstein to the top of the charts, and later Janis Joplin doing the same for Kristofferson’s ‘Me and Bobby McGee’.
While not all of the songs performed that night were written in that room, nor were those the only songs to have been performed, it was certainly a legendary moment in musical history, where unfinished versions of some of the most beloved tracks in rock history were all showcased to an exclusive party of esteemed songwriters.
Never Miss A Tale
The Far Out Bob Dylan Newsletter
All the latest stories about Bob Dylan from the independent voice of culture.
Straight to your inbox.