Cameron Winter explains why no one will ever understand Bob Dylan: “Nobody really has a clue”
The phrase “never meet your heroes” was probably invented after a Bob Dylan fan met the legendary songwriter.
Because ultimately, Dylan’s gruffness is wrapped up in his greatness. His razor-sharp societal observations come from an unflinching honesty, and his artistic innovation builds upon a ruthlessly uncompromising nature. So love his music all you like, but don’t expect a warm handshake and an extension of gratitude for your fandom, were you to secure a meet and greet.
But Dylan fandom is entering an entirely new era in 2025. A new generation, funnelling in through internet education and vanity-ridden biopics, is inbound, and gatekeepers of the Dylan-verse are worried. One of which is the artist many new critics are comparing to Dylan: Cameron Winter.
It’s safe to say that Winter wasn’t a fan of Dylan’s story being folded into the biopic mixture, for it bred what he perceives to be a misguided fetishism of his career thereafter. Because somewhere in the process of casting Hollywood sweetheart Timothée Chalamet as the aloof songwriter has almost turned Dylan into a cinematic hunk.
“The world needs to be ready for the unforeseen consequences of a hunked-up Bob Dylan revival,” Winter explained.
He continued, “Bob Dylan has been toying with his mythical status and untouchable legacy for the past 50 years similarly to how a bored prince might toy with the peasantry, switching religions, switching voices, going on Pawn Stars, game shows etc, and I see his enthusiastic collaboration with this lame-ass biopic as just another link in the chain of his seeing how far he can push the public until they realize that he’s just some weird dude who spent 7 years being dizzyingly famous.”
“The youth will come to understand Bob Dylan as a cool righteous hipster with abs,” he added. “I don’t see it that way, but I guess the beautiful thing about Bob Dylan is that all his biggest fans are convinced that they understand the real ‘Bob Dylan’ even though nobody really has a clue.”
It’s Bob Dylan’s world, and we are all just playing in it, according to Winter. And given his track record and how little enthusiasm he shows when it comes to engaging with slick entertainment marketing rollouts, like the one for A Complete Unknown, his brief albeit powerful approval of the project does, in fact, hint that there is some truth to what Winter is saying.
It’s also true that a biopic of an artist like Dylan feels inherently contradictory to him as a person. Music is the perfect platform for someone of his intelligence and nuance, because it provides a brief window into his mind, before shutting the curtains and allowing a more subjective consideration to take place.
Movies and biopics in particular differ in the fact that they provide a much more objective view of a life that was packed with nuance. There’s no way to truly know whether the Dylan biopic faithfully represented the truth of his lived experience, and what Winter rightly outlines is that, dangerously, A Complete Unknown tries to do that. Not understanding Dylan isn’t a problem; in fact, it’s what makes him one of the greatest.
Never Miss A Tale
The Far Out Bob Dylan Newsletter
All the latest stories about Bob Dylan from the independent voice of culture.
Straight to your inbox.