Bob Dylan discusses the meaning of minor and major keys
Bob Dylan is widely considered to be one of the greatest songwriters of all time, a legacy that largely stems from his lyrical brilliance. Beginning in the 1960s, he filled his songs with collective observations and frustrations about the world around him, infusing protest and politics with vivid imagery and poetic flair. But his mastery of melody is also something to be admired.
Though many have criticised Dylan for his imperfect vocal style, there is a certain beauty to his witty and gritty singing. There’s a beauty, too, to the memorable melodies through which he delivers his poetry and politics. His compositions often serve his storytelling, enhancing it in feeling and impact, ensuring that audiences will be singing along for generations to come.
For example, ‘Knockin’ On Heaven’s Door’, one of Dylan’s signature tracks, shows off his exceptional lyrics, even when they’re in their simplest form. “Mama put my guns in the ground, I can’t shoot them anymore,” he sings, “That long black cloud is coming down, I feel like I’m knockin’ on heaven’s door.” It paints a vivid picture even without the film it accompanied, but it’s musically memorable, too.
The chorus, which simply repeats the title over and over, is unforgettable. It’s as simple and straightforward as the lyrics, made up of just four easy chords, but it’s somehow memorable enough to have garnered countless covers in the decades since its initial release. But how does Dylan match lyrical meaning to sonic feeling so expertly?
Perhaps it’s due to the unique way he sees keys and chords. During a conversation with Playboy, the legendary songwriter was prompted to explain how he connects certain keys to certain moods, starting out with B major and B-flat major. “Each one is hard to define,” he prefaced, “Assume the characteristic that is true of both of them and you’ll find you’re not sure whether you’re speaking to them or to their echo.”
In a more sweeping comment, Dylan suggested that any major key deals with romance, while any minor deals with the supernatural. “I find C major to be the key of strength, but also the key of regret,” he added, a comment that further clarifies the compositional genius of the ‘Knockin’ On Heaven’s Door’ chorus, which ends in a C, leaving a feeling of regret behind.
Dylan went on to call E major “the key of confidence,” while he saw A-flat major as the “key of renunciation.” The songwriter clearly makes distinct connections between chords and moods, connections that he then utilises to drive home his lyricism. As a listener, it’s eye-opening to learn how this process works and to understand more deeply how he creates a feeling of romance with major chords or of regret with a C major.
While Dylan is undoubtedly most well-known for his talent with a pen and paper, his lyrics are made all the more effective thanks to his ability to forge the right melodies to accompany them, whether that’s with guitars, keys, or even a harmonica. His understanding of how to create a mood extends beyond words and into musical composition. Alongside his groundbreaking lyrics, it is this that has allowed his songwriting to retain relevance and reverence for so long.
Never Miss A Tale
The Far Out Bob Dylan Newsletter
All the latest stories about Bob Dylan from the independent voice of culture.
Straight to your inbox.